Entry 2 · Case one
Case one: HR and payroll software, India. September 2026.
The source of the "36 answers", "1 vendor in all 36", "10 vanished" and the chart on the home page, and of the Case one report.
- CategoryHR, HRMS and payroll software bought by companies in India.
- QuestionsSix. Written the way a buyer asks, with no company named. Listed word for word below. The wording was locked on 17 September 2026 and not changed between runs.
- AssistantsChatGPT, Perplexity and Gemini, used through their normal web interfaces, not through developer access.
- RunsRun 1: Thursday 17 September 2026. Run 2: Tuesday 22 September 2026. Each run asked all six questions once on each assistant: 18 answers per run, 36 in total. A third run was planned for 29 September and was not done. This case uses two runs.
- SessionA fresh, logged-out or private session for each question. Nothing said about testing visibility. No follow-up prompts.
- Asked fromCase one was asked from India.
- RecordEvery answer saved in full as a text file, with the sources the assistant showed, in the same folder as this count. The files are kept for inspection on request.
- Counting ruleA vendor counts as named in an answer if its name appears anywhere in the answer text, in any case. A name that appears only in the assistant's list of sources does not count. Product names of the same company count once for that company. Counting was done by a script against a watch list of 59 vendor names. The script and the list are kept with the answer files.
- The three hero figures36 = 6 questions × 3 assistants × 2 runs. 1 = one vendor was named in all 18 answers of run 1 and all 18 of run 2. 10 = vendors named at least once on 17 September and in none of the 18 answers on 22 September.
- The chartVendors A to D were named in 36, 34, 31 and 28 of the 36 answers. Six more vendors were named between 10 and 20 times (20, 19, 16, 14, 11 and 10). Eighteen vendors were named three times or fewer, eight of them exactly once. Twenty-eight vendors from the watch list were named at least once.
- Names withheldWe do not publish vendor names from this test, because we may work with any of them. The letters A to D are the same vendors on every page.
The six questions, word for word
- What's the best HRMS for a company in India?
- What's the best payroll software for Indian PF, ESI and TDS compliance?
- What's the best HR and payroll platform for a 100-person company in India?
- What's the best HR software for Indian startups and SMBs?
- Which HRMS platforms are recommended for companies with employees across multiple Indian cities?
- What are the most recommended HRMS tools for a mid-sized Indian company?
What we don't claim from this test
- It covers one category in one country on two days. It does not predict what the assistants say about your category.
- Two runs is a small sample. The 10-vendor swing between runs is itself the finding: a single answer proves nothing.
- Assistants change between runs and between accounts. Your own result on the same question may differ.
- The watch list could miss a vendor we did not think to list. If you are an HR-software vendor and were named in an answer we missed, write to us and we will correct the count.