A client Diagnostic asks your own six questions three times per assistant: 54 answers, plus a by-name check. This sample uses the two runs of the public test, so it has 36 answers and no by-name check. The layout is the same.
In one minute
- 14 of 36 answers named Company X.1 Six of 18 on 17 September; eight of 18 on 22 September.
- 6 of 6 answers to the payroll-compliance question named it.1 The two questions about mid-sized and multi-city companies: 0 of 12.
- 3 of 14 answers showed Company X's own website as a source.1 Seven showed Vendor A's.
- Company X owns one question. Every assistant names it when the buyer asks about payroll compliance, and most of the time when the buyer is a startup or small business.
- It disappears when the buyer gets bigger. Not one of the 12 answers about mid-sized or multi-city companies named it, and when a larger company is mentioned it comes with a caveat: "limited", "less compelling for a mature full HRMS".
- The assistants describe it partly from competitors' comparison pages. ChatGPT cites one by name as the source for what Company X does.
Named, by assistant
Twelve answers per assistant: six questions, two runs (a Diagnostic uses three).
- ChatGPT5 of 12
- Perplexity4 of 12
- Gemini5 of 12
| Assistant | 17 Sep, of 6 | 22 Sep, of 6 | Total, of 12 |
|---|---|---|---|
| ChatGPT | 3 | 2 | 5 |
| Perplexity | 2 | 2 | 4 |
| Gemini | 1 | 4 | 5 |
Gemini named Company X once on 17 September and four times on 22 September, on the same six questions. One run is not a result.
Named, by question
Six answers per question: three assistants, two runs.
- Q1 · best HRMS1 of 6
- Q2 · payroll compliance6 of 6
- Q3 · 100-person company3 of 6
- Q4 · startups and SMBs4 of 6
- Q5 · multiple cities0 of 6
- Q6 · mid-sized company0 of 6
| Question | Named, of 6 | By whom |
|---|---|---|
| What's the best HRMS for a company in India? | 1 | Gemini, 22 Sep |
| What's the best payroll software for Indian PF, ESI and TDS compliance? | 6 | All three, both runs |
| What's the best HR and payroll platform for a 100-person company in India? | 3 | ChatGPT, 17 Sep; Gemini and Perplexity, 22 Sep |
| What's the best HR software for Indian startups and SMBs? | 4 | ChatGPT and Perplexity, 17 Sep; ChatGPT and Gemini, 22 Sep |
| Which HRMS platforms are recommended for companies with employees across multiple Indian cities? | 0 | — |
| What are the most recommended HRMS tools for a mid-sized Indian company? | 0 | — |
What was said, word for word
Company and product names replaced with the letters used across this site, in square brackets. Nothing else changed.
"Choose [Company X] if salary disbursement and automated statutory payments are your priority, or [Vendor C's payroll product] if you already use [Vendor C's other products]."
Perplexity · 17 September 2026 · question 2
"For a 100-person company in India, you hit the sweet spot where basic startup payroll tools (like [Company X]) become limited, and expensive enterprise platforms (like [Vendor D]) are overkill."
Gemini · 22 September 2026 · question 3
"[Company X] — Startups prioritising payroll execution, payouts, and contractor workflows — Less compelling for a mature full HRMS."
Perplexity · 22 September 2026 · question 3, from a comparison table
In a client report every one of the 54 answers is included in full, with the by-name answer from each assistant: what it says about you, what it gets wrong, and what it warns buyers about.
The source map
The websites the assistants showed as sources with the 14 answers that named Company X. Gemini showed no sources with any of its five answers; the other nine answers showed fourteen different sites between them.
| Source | Shown with how many of the 14 answers |
|---|---|
| Vendor A's website | 7 |
| Vendor B's website | 5 |
| Vendor C's website, including its comparison page | 5 |
| Company X's own website | 3 |
| Vendor E's website | 2 |
| Vendors D, F and G's websites | 1 each |
| Three other vendors' websites | 1 each |
| Three third-party listing or blog sites | 1 each |
Ten of the fourteen sources are competitors' own websites. One of ChatGPT's answers says, in its own words, that a competitor's comparison page is where it learned what Company X does. The assistants are learning the market from the vendors that publish the most comparison content, and describing Company X from those pages, in the slot those pages give it.
Where the work would start
In a Diagnostic, the first fix is chosen from this map and set up with the client's team. For a company in Company X's position, the candidates are a page of its own facts that answers what competitors' comparison pages say about it, where it is framed as a startup tool, and its own review and listing profiles. The two questions where it never appears, about mid-sized and multi-city companies, drew on vendors' own sites and third-party articles, not listing sites. Those answers are not in this map, which covers only the 14 answers that named Company X; a placement in someone else's article is never promised. Which of these candidates comes first depends on the by-name check, which this sample does not include.
No fix is promised to move the answer. In monthly work, the same questions are rerun and the rate is reported against this baseline, whichever way it moves.
What we don't claim
- Two runs is a small sample. A client Diagnostic uses three.
- The sources shown are the ones the assistants displayed. They may have read more than they showed, and Gemini showed none.
- Company X did not ask for this and has not seen it. That is why it is anonymised, and why we will remove it on request.