Case one · HR and payroll software · India

Who AI recommends for HR and payroll software in India.

Six questions a buyer asks, with no company in them. ChatGPT, Perplexity and Gemini, asked on two days five days apart. Thirty-six answers, every one on file. Here is who they named, and how much the answer moved.

September 2026Published 6 October 2026How this was countedAll research

In one minute

  • 36 answers. 6 questions × 3 assistants × 2 runs (17 and 22 September 2026).1
  • 1 vendor named in all 36 answers.1 The next three: 34, 31 and 28.
  • 10 vendors named on 17 September and not once on 22 September.1
  • Twenty-eight vendors were named at least once. Four of them took most of the shortlist.
  • Eighteen vendors were named three times or fewer. Eight were named exactly once in 36 answers.
  • The assistants disagree with each other. Vendor D was named in 12 of 12 Perplexity answers and 6 of 12 Gemini answers.
  • Vendor names are withheld, because we may work with any of them. The letters are the same on every page of this site.

The questions

Asked word for word, in fresh sessions, with nothing said about testing. Wording locked on 17 September.

  1. What's the best HRMS for a company in India?
  2. What's the best payroll software for Indian PF, ESI and TDS compliance?
  3. What's the best HR and payroll platform for a 100-person company in India?
  4. What's the best HR software for Indian startups and SMBs?
  5. Which HRMS platforms are recommended for companies with employees across multiple Indian cities?
  6. What are the most recommended HRMS tools for a mid-sized Indian company?

Who was named, out of 36 answers

  1. Vendor A36 of 36
  2. Vendor B34 of 36
  3. Vendor C31 of 36
  4. Vendor D28 of 36
  5. Vendor E20 of 36
  6. Vendor F19 of 36
  7. Vendor G16 of 36
  8. Vendor H14 of 36
  9. Vendor I11 of 36
  10. Vendor J10 of 36
  11. 18 other vendors named at least once3 or fewer of 36

Count = answers in which the vendor's name appears, out of 36. Counted by script against a watch list of 59 vendor names.1

How much the answer moved in five days

The same six questions, the same three assistants, five days apart. If AI answers were stable, the two columns would match.

Ten vendors named at least once on 17 September and in none of the 18 answers on 22 September.1

Vendor17 Sep, of 1822 Sep, of 18Change
Vendor A1818None
Vendor B1618+2
Vendor C1516+1
Vendor D1315+2
Vendor E119−2
Vendor F613+7, the biggest swing
Vendor G610+4
Vendor H68+2
Vendor I47+3
Vendor J46+2
10 vendors1 to 3 each0Named on 17 Sep, gone on 22 Sep
1 vendor01New on 22 Sep

Of the 59 names on the watch list, 27 vendors were named on 17 September and 18 on 22 September; 17 were named on both days.1

The assistants don't agree with each other

Out of 12 answers per assistant (six questions, two runs):

VendorChatGPT, of 12Perplexity, of 12Gemini, of 12
Vendor A121212
Vendor B121111
Vendor C12118
Vendor D10126

A vendor that checks only ChatGPT would see a different market from one that checks only Gemini. Gemini named about five vendors per answer on average in this test; ChatGPT about seven; Perplexity about eight.1

What this means if you sell HR or payroll software in India

  • The shortlist is short, and it is already taken. Four vendors appear in most answers. If you are not one of them, a buyer who asks an assistant will usually not hear your name.
  • One screenshot proves nothing. Ten vendors appeared on one day and vanished five days later. The useful number is a rate over repeated runs, not a single answer.
  • Check all three assistants. They name different vendors from the same question. Your buyers use all three.
  • The fix starts at the source. Most answers show the websites they read; some show none. Those pages, more than your home page, decide whether you are named. Some of them are yours. The Diagnostic maps them for your questions.

What we don't claim

  • This is one category, one country, two days. It does not predict your category.
  • Two runs is a small sample. That is why the result is published as counts, not as a ranking, and why vendor names are withheld.
  • We do not control what the assistants say, and nothing here promises a place on the shortlist.
  • If you are a vendor in this test and want your own row, with your name, ask. We will send it privately.

Ask for your row

Method, dates, sessions and counting rule: seenovalabs.com/method. Raw answer files are kept with their cited sources and can be inspected on request.

Want your own row?

This is one category. We run the same test in yours: your buyers' questions, in your category and country, three times per assistant, with every answer on record.