Case two · HR and payroll software · India

Who AI recommends for HR and payroll software in India, October 2026.

On 22 October 2026 we asked ChatGPT, Perplexity and Gemini six questions a buyer asks, from India, with no company named, in a fresh chat each time: 18 answers, every one on file.

22 October 2026Published 27 October 2026How we askedAll research

In one minute

  • 18 answers. 6 questions × 3 assistants, each asked once, in a single run.1
  • 3 vendors named in all 18 answers.1
  • 19 vendors named at least once. Eight of them were named only once.1
  • The assistants disagree. Vendor O was named in 1 of 6 ChatGPT answers but 4 of 6 on each of the others. ChatGPT named 8 different vendors, Perplexity 14 and Gemini 15.1
  • Vendor names are withheld, because we may work with any of them. This page uses its own letters, K to U, which do not match Case one's.

How we asked

  • ChatGPT: signed out, in Chrome Incognito. Its source tags would not open, so only its inline links are on record.
  • Perplexity: signed in, free plan, with its own incognito mode on.
  • Gemini: signed in, on a research account; no sources shown. One question was re-asked after an error.
  • One run, not three: each question once per assistant. Counts are out of 18, or 6 per assistant.
  • Counting: the same rule as Case one. A vendor counts when its name appears anywhere in the answer text; a name shown only as a source does not count. One company's products count once.
  • Not like-for-like with Case one: in September, Perplexity and Gemini were signed out. Compare the two pages with care.

The questions

Word for word, unchanged since 17 September 2026.

  1. What's the best HRMS for a company in India?
  2. What's the best payroll software for Indian PF, ESI and TDS compliance?
  3. What's the best HR and payroll platform for a 100-person company in India?
  4. What's the best HR software for Indian startups and SMBs?
  5. Which HRMS platforms are recommended for companies with employees across multiple Indian cities?
  6. What are the most recommended HRMS tools for a mid-sized Indian company?

Who was named, out of 18 answers

  1. Vendor K18 of 18
  2. Vendor L18 of 18
  3. Vendor M18 of 18
  4. Vendor N13 of 18
  5. Vendor O9 of 18
  6. Vendor P8 of 18
  7. Vendor Q7 of 18
  8. Vendor R6 of 18
  9. Vendor S5 of 18
  10. Vendor T2 of 18
  11. Vendor U2 of 18
  12. 8 other vendors named once each1 of 18

Count = answers, out of 18, whose text names the vendor. Each answer named 3 to 11 vendors, about 6 on average.1

The payroll question

“What's the best payroll software for Indian PF, ESI and TDS compliance?” ChatGPT named 4 vendors, Gemini 5 and Perplexity 6. All three named K, L, M and Q. Gemini added N, and Perplexity added N and R.1

Where the answers read

The answers showed 89 links: 60 from Perplexity, 29 from ChatGPT and none from Gemini.1

  • 73 of 89 went to vendors' own websites: 65 to vendors named in these answers, 8 to vendors no answer named. Vendor K's site had 15 links, Vendor L's 11.
  • 16 of 89 went to third-party pages, such as linkedin.com (4 links), cio.economictimes.indiatimes.com (3) and intervue.io (2).
  • ChatGPT showed only inline links, all to vendors named in the same answer.
  • Perplexity linked almost only to lists or comparisons of HR software (59 of 60, by title or web address), 44 of them on vendors' sites.

What changed since 19 October

We asked the same questions on 19 October. Vendors K and L were named in all 18 answers on both days. One caveat: that day, signed out, Perplexity asked us to sign up instead of answering, so we signed in as an exception. We do not compare the other counts here, because the two days were not recorded under exactly the same setup.

What this is, and what it is not

  • What this is: a dated record of one run: 18 answers, each saved word for word with its links.
  • Not a ranking, a forecast or a promise. One run is a small sample, and the next may differ. We publish counts, not places, and we do not control what the assistants say.
  • If you sell HR or payroll software in India and want your own row, with your name, ask. We will send it privately.

Ask for your row

1. How we measure: seenovalabs.com/method. Answer files are kept with their links and can be inspected on request.

Want your own row?

This is one category, asked once. We run the same test in yours: your buyers' questions, three times per assistant, with every answer on record.